Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Menus

Cafe Between serves as a neighborhood spot that hums in the morning, buzzes in the afternoon, and is filled with vibrant energy in the evening.

Located at 118 12th Ave S, the cafe is a place to gather, enjoy delectable food, and sip on a beverage of your choice.

Starters and Boards

  • Chef’s Board

    $22

    Chef’s selection of daily cheese, cured meats, and accompaniments

  • Country Poutine

    $14

    Hand-cut fries, country sausage gravy, Wisconsin cheese curds, chives

  • Short Ribs

    $16

    Tender & slow-cooked, hickory bourbon BBQ glaze

  • Fried Green Tomatoes

    $13

    Country-fried green tomatoes, pickled red onions, frisée, buttermilk herb drizzle

  • Truffle Fries

    $13

    Shoestring fries, white truffle, frisée, parmesan, petite herbs

  • Pretzel and Curd Board

    $12

    Buttered soft pretzel, cheese curds, beer cheese, mustard

  • Nashville Hot Shrimp

    $16

    Creamy stone cheese grits

  • Wings

    $14

    Choose from: ginger sesame | smoked & rubbed | buffalo caramel | ancho mezcal BBQ

Artisanal Pizza

  • Truffle

    $18

    Garlic mornay, roasted mushrooms, roasted garlic, white truffle, cured egg yolk, arugula

  • Carne

    $18

    Zesty tomato sauce, sausage, pepperoni, speck ham, mozzarella

  • Nashville

    $18

    Fried chicken, Nashville hot honey, pickled cucumber, herbed buttermilk drizzle

  • Margherita

    $18

    Fresh mozzarella, basil, zesty tomato sauce

  • Chef’s Special Pizza

    $18

    Ask us about today’s special creation!

  • BYOP (Build Your Own Pizza)

    $18

    Veggies: mushroom, roasted garlic, tomato, arugula
    Meats: pepperoni, sausage, speck, bacon, fried chicken
    Cheeses: mozzarella, provolone, parmesan
    Add-ons: truffle oil, buttermilk dressing, Nashville honey

Salads and Sandwiches

Sandwiches served with fries

  • Beetween Salad

    $16

    Roasted beets, arugula & frisée, goat cheese, brown butter granola, honey citrus vinaigrette

  • Café Caesar

    $16

    Crisp romaine, parmesan, charred lemon, classic Caesar dressing, garlic butter croutons

  • Kale & Apple

    $14

    Shaved Tuscan kale, pink lady apple, parmesan, candied walnuts, togarashi, honey citrus vinaigrette

    Add Shrimp $6

    Add Chicken $4

  • Chicken Balt

    $18

    Nashville fried chicken, heritage bacon, smashed avocado, roasted tomato, arugula, brioche bun

  • Big Kid Grilled Cheese

    $15

    Gruyere, provolone, parmesan, roasted mushrooms, arugula, sourdough

  • Pro Panini

    $16

    Prosciutto, fig jam, provolone, arugula, smashed hoagie roll

  • Cafe Burger

    $18

    Grass-fed beef, bourbon red onion jam, bacon, sharp provolone, arugula, roasted tomato, brioche bun, aioli

Entrées

  • Seasonal Risotto

    $22

    Delicata squash, candied walnut, sage, spinach, parmesan, black garlic brown butter

  • Southern Surprise

    $24

    Fried chicken, bacon-braised kale, mac n’ cheese, country gravy, buttermilk biscuit

  • Short Rib Gnocchi

    $26

    Potato gnocchi, red wine short rib ragout, goat cheese, arugula

  • Shrimp Tortellini

    $24

    Tiger shrimp, leek, grape tomato, white wine, garlic butter

Dessert

  • Mixed Berry Bread Pudding

    $10

    Fresh berries, buttery croissants, house made whipped cream

  • Peanut Butter Skillet Cookie

    $10

    Topped with salted caramel ice cream and chocolate sauce

  • Basque Cheesecake

    $10

    Topped with blueberry compote and roasted pecan pieces

  • Salted Caramel Ice Cream

    $5

Breakfast Served Everyday until 11 Am

  • Full American Breakfast

    $23

    Two farm eggs any style, crispy heritage bacon, sausage links, breakfast potatoes, toasted buttermilk drop biscuit, seasonal fruit*

  • Biscuits & Gravy

    $22

    Buttermilk drop biscuits, country gravy, farm eggs, gulch dust

  • Hipster Toast

    $16

    Grilled sourdough, smashed avocado, farm eggs, pickled fresno peppers, grape tomatoes, radish, gulch dust

    vegan

  • Creamy Cheese Grits

    Creamy stone cheese grits

    $14

    Add bacon $3

    Add shrimp $4

    Add sausage $2

  • Chicken and Waffle

    $21

    Buttermilk fried chicken, malted waffle, country gravy syrup

  • Churro Pancakes

    $16

    Dulce de leche, strawberries, cinnamon

Coffee

Coffee Classics

  • Espresso

    Single or double

    12oz $4

    16oz $7

  • Americano

    12oz $4

    16oz $6

  • Cappuccino

    12oz $4

    16oz $6

  • Latte

    12oz $4

    16oz $6

  • Macchiato

    12oz $4

    16oz $6

  • Bongo Blend

    12oz $4

    16oz $6

  • Iced Coffee

    12oz $4

    16oz $6

  • Nitro Cold Brew

    12oz $5

    16oz $7

Specialty Coffee

12oz - $5 / 16oz - $7

  • Mocha

  • Caramel Macchiato

  • Vanilla Latte

  • Iced Latte

Tea

12oz - $4 / 16oz - $6

  • Herbal Infusions

    Chamomile, peppermint, lemon balm

  • Black Tea

    English breakfast, Earl Grey, Darjeeling

  • Green, Chai & Matcha

  • Milks

    Whole, 2%, half & half

    Specialty milks — almond, soy, oat $1

  • Syrups

    $1

    Vanilla, sugar-free vanilla, hazelnut, caramel, sugar-free caramel, seasonal favorites

Pastries

Assorted pastries & baked goods in case at counter

Bites

Light and Fresh

  • Berry Bliss Parfait

    $7

    Vanilla Greek yogurt, fresh seasonal berries, granola

  • Tropical Sunrise Parfait

    $7

    Coconut yogurt, mango, pineapple, toasted coconut

  • Overnight Oats

    $6

    Rolled oats soaked in almond milk with chia seeds, honey, seasonal fruit

  • Protein Power Box

    $10

    Hard-boiled egg, sharp cheddar, apple slices, whole-grain crackers

  • Avocado Toast Box

    $10

    Smashed avocado on multigrain toast, cherry tomatoes, feta, “everything bagel" seasoning

Breakfast Sandwiches

  • The Classic

    $10

    Scrambled eggs, crispy bacon, cheddar cheese, buttery croissant

  • Southwest Sunrise

    $10

    Scrambled eggs, chorizo, pepper jack cheese, chipotle aioli, toasted brioche bun

  • Veggie & Swiss

    $8

    Fluffy eggs, sautéed spinach, mushrooms, Swiss cheese, English muffin

Bar Menu

  • Chef's Board

    $18

    Chef's selection of daily cheese, cured meats, and accompaniments

  • Country Poutine

    $12

    Hand-cut 7 fries, country sausage gravy, Wisconsin cheese curds, chives

  • Short Ribs

    $14

    Tender & slow-cooked, hickory bourbon BBQ glaze

  • Fried Green Tomatoes

    $12

    Country-fried green tomatoes, pickled red onions, frisée, buttermilk herb drizzle

  • Truffle Fries

    $12

    Shoestring fries, white truffle, frisée, parmesan, petite herbs

  • Pretzel & Curd Board

    $12

    Buttered soft pretzel, cheese curds, beer cheese, mustard

  • Nashville Hot Shrimp

    $16

    Creamy stone cheese grits

  • Wings

    $14

    Choose from: ginger sesame, smoked & rubbed, buffalo caramel, Ancho Mezcal BBQ, gochujang

Signature Cocktails

$16

  • Mezcal Negroni

    A smoky twist on the classic, featuring mezcal, Campari, and sweet vermouth, garnished with an orange peel

  • Spiced Pear Martini

    A cozy blend of spiced pear vodka, elderflower liqueur, and a hint of lemon, finished with a cinnamon sugar rim

  • Black Manhattan

    A bold and bittersweet variation made with rye whiskey, Amaro, and Angostura bitters, garnished with a Luxardo cherry.

  • Maple Old Fashioned

    A fall-inspired take on the classic, combining bourbon, pure maple syrup, and orange bitters, garnished with an orange twist

  • Chai Espresso Martini

    A decadent mix of vodka, espresso, chai spice liqueur, and coffee liqueur, topped with a dusting of chai spice

  • Aviation

    A timeless cocktail with gin, Maraschino liqueur, crème de violette, and fresh lemon juice, served with a lemon twist

  • Limoncello Cosmo

    A refreshing blend of limoncello, vodka, Triple sec, and cranberry juice, with a splash of lime, garnished with a lemon wheel

Draft Beer

$7

  • Mich Ultra

  • Tailgate Orange Wheat

  • Tennessee Brew Works Hippie IPA

  • Wiseacre Tiny Bomb Pilsner

Bottled Beer

  • Domestic

    $9

    Bud Light

    Michelob Ultra

    Budweiser

  • Specialty

    $10

    Lagunitas

    New Belgium Fat Tire

    The Athletic NA

  • Imported

    $10

    Stella Artois

    Heineken

    Modelo Especial

Wine by The Glass

  • Red Wine

    Twenty Acres Cabernet Sauvignon, California $11

    Bread and Butter Pinot Noir, Bright California $13

    Line 39 Petite Sirah, California $9

  • White Wine

    Twenty Acres Chardonnay, California $12

    Juggernaut Sauvignon Blanc, New Zealand $13

    Kim Crawford Pinot Grigio, New Zealand $13

  • Bubbles

    $15

    La Marca Prosecco, Italy

Dessert

  • Mixed Berry Bread Pudding

    $10

    Fresh berries, buttery croissants, house made whipped cream

  • Peanut Butter Skillet Cookie

    $10

    Topped with salted caramel ice cream and chocolate sauce

  • Basque Cheesecake

    $10

    Topped with blueberry compote and roasted pecan pieces

  • Salted Caramel Ice Cream

    $5

Email Signup

Please check errors in the form above
Thank you for signing up for email updates!
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.